Tech Giant Fall: Trigger for New Stock Market Crash?
On Thursday night, a significant market turmoil unfolded in the United States, leading to a drastic drop in commodities such as gold, the dollar, stocks, Treasury bonds, and even Bitcoin. This broad sell-off of dollar assets has left many analysts and investors searching for a deeper understanding of the underlying factors driving this unusual market behavior.
At the forefront of this decline were the seven major tech companies that have long supported the bullish U.S. stock market. The narrative circling around the Wall Street community is that the downturn was primarily triggered by the shifting dynamics of the upcoming U.S. presidential election. With reports suggesting that Donald Trump could potentially lose critical swing states, the optimism surrounding “Trump trades” waned significantly. However, this interpretation only scratches the surface; mainstream media outlets were largely silent on the more nuanced and complex reasons behind this market plunge.
Adding to the allure of conspiracy theories, some market observers speculate that Wall Street traders are exerting pressure on the Federal Reserve ahead of its upcoming meeting. The implication here is stark: if the Fed does not follow through with a 25 basis point rate cut in November, it could catalyze another financial crisis. This speculation feeds into a broader narrative surrounding financial manipulation and the strategic actions of market players as they position themselves for a rapidly evolving economic landscape.
Advertisement
The trigger event came after the U.S. released its core PCE price index for September, which exceeded expectations for year-over-year growth. Simultaneously, the number of individuals applying for unemployment benefits dropped significantly, indicating potential shifts in the labor market. This economic data sparked immediate concerns within the financial community, suggesting that the Federal Reserve might reconsider its easing strategies, which contradicted Wall Street's prevailing belief in the certainty of a rate drop.
For over a month, Wall Street was operating under the assumption that there was a 90% chance of a rate cut in November, but this newly released economic data contradicted that outlook, igniting panic across financial institutions. If the Federal Reserve decides to pause its rate-cutting agenda at this critical juncture, the impact on stock prices could be severe, as summers change rapidly when monetary policies shift direction.
Reflecting the tension in the markets, the AI sector within the U.S. stock market saw significant losses as of Thursday night. Notable declines included Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) dropping 11% in just two days, and Microsoft, Meta, Nvidia, Google, Tesla, Apple, and Amazon all showing marked decreases in their stock prices with some experiencing their largest single-day declines in years. With the average valuation of the seven largest tech companies sitting at a relative high of 28.9 times earnings, the apprehension among investors is palpable.
Adding to the complexity, when analyzing the trailing P/E ratio over the past ten years, the S&P 500 now boasts a valuation of 37 times earnings. This figure places it near the third-highest peak in the last 150 years, surpassed only by the infamous dot-com bubble associated with the year 2000. It indicates that the recent surge in tech stock prices has been primarily fueled by significant amounts of money flowing into the market, largely attributable to conditions maintained by the Federal Reserve rather than genuine performance improvements among tech companies.
The total market capitalization of U.S. equities has seen staggering growth, reportedly reaching $85.7 trillion in the second quarter of 2024. The famed Warren Buffett indicator, which compares total stock market capitalization to GDP, has now exceeded an alarming 200%, indicating that the stock market's value is over twice that of the U.S. economy. Such an imbalance raises serious concerns about the sustainability of the current market conditions.
In this context, should the Federal Reserve choose to abandon its rate-cutting approach in November, it could fundamentally change the dynamics of the stock market. The fear emanating from Wall Street is not just about an immediate downturn, but rather about the absence of new liquidity entering the market to sustain inflated stock prices. This anxiety manifested itself in the selling frenzy that unfolded.
The turbulence was compounded by a slew of third-quarter earnings reports released by major tech companies. Although Google performed relatively well, both Microsoft and Meta struggled, projecting further unease about the sector's commitment to AI. Despite the large-scale investments these companies are making toward AI initiatives, tangible profits remain elusive, raising questions about their long-term sustainability and strategy. The current trajectory of increasing expenditure is expected to persist well into 2025, further adding fuel to the anxiety of investors.
The landscape is further complicated by reports of potential financial misconduct within the AI sector, specifically surfacing from companies like AMD. Such occurrences could lead to a ripple effect, causing investor scrutiny to heighten across the entire sector, limiting the market’s willingness to gamble on AI-centric investments. Companies that previously skirted by on hype may find themselves exposed as profitability becomes a clearer requirement.
Overall, the AI market has become a hotbed for speculation, where any company associated with AI can seemingly thrive in the capital markets. Yet amidst the global financial instability, authorities may find themselves hesitant to burst this bubble. The growing discrepancy between actual performance and speculative valuations raises the stakes considerably. Should core companies begin to falter, the shaky foundation of speculative investments is likely to crumble rapidly.
While AI represents groundbreaking advancements in productivity, expectations often run too high, leading investors to overestimate the potential immediate impact. Conversely, they may underestimate the profound long-term changes that AI is capable of producing. However, these shifting expectations are not merely a reflection of technological progression but reveal wider truths about market psychology and the cyclical nature of speculation.
Ultimately, these recent developments illustrate that numerous factors are at play in shaping Wall Street's investment strategies. This complex interplay of technology, economic indicators, and investor sentiment underscores the importance of a broader understanding of the financial climate. Economic resilience and corporate performance must be balanced against speculative fervor to navigate these uncertain waters ahead.